Surfshark vs ProtonVPN

Surfshark is the value pick for households with lots of devices; ProtonVPN is the pick if a genuinely unlimited free tier matters more than price on the paid plan. When comparing Surfshark vs Proton VPN, both services combine strong security with modern VPN features, but they target slightly different users. Surfshark focuses on value, unlimited device connections, and a broad set of everyday privacy tools, while Proton VPN places greater emphasis on transparency, advanced privacy, and its security-focused infrastructure. The main difference comes down to priorities. Surfshark is better for households and users who want to protect many devices with one subscription, while Proton VPN is particularly attractive to privacy-focused users who value open-source apps and advanced features such as Secure Core.

Surfshark logo Surfshark 9.3/10 ProtonVPN logo ProtonVPN 9.1/10

Swipe sideways to see both columns →

Criterion Surfshark ProtonVPN
Starting price $2.19/mo (2-yr plan) $4.49/mo (2-yr plan)
Free plan No Yes, no data cap
No-logs audit Deloitte SEC Consult
Open source apps No Yes
Simultaneous connections Unlimited 10
Kill switch Yes Yes

Surfshark vs Proton VPN: Privacy and Security

Both VPNs use strong encryption and modern protocols such as WireGuard. They also provide essential security features including a kill switch and protection against common IP and DNS leaks.

Surfshark adds several privacy tools beyond a standard VPN connection. Dynamic MultiHop can route traffic through two VPN servers, while obfuscated servers help disguise VPN usage. CleanWeb is designed to block ads, trackers, and malicious content. Surfshark also operates RAM-only server infrastructure.

Proton VPN has an especially strong privacy focus. Its apps are open source and regularly undergo independent security audits. Secure Core routes traffic through hardened servers in privacy-friendly countries before sending it to the final VPN server. Proton VPN also includes NetShield for blocking ads, trackers, and malware.

Both provide strong security, but Proton VPN has an advantage for users who prioritize transparency and advanced privacy architecture.

Speed and Server Network

VPN speed depends on your location, server distance, protocol, and network conditions, so performance will vary between users.

Surfshark supports WireGuard and operates more than 4,500 servers worldwide. Its network provides plenty of options for browsing, streaming, gaming, and other everyday activities.

Proton VPN also supports WireGuard and uses VPN Accelerator technology to improve performance, particularly over long-distance connections. Its network covers more than 140 countries, giving users extensive geographic choice.

Both are competitive for everyday performance. Surfshark provides a large network and straightforward connections, while Proton VPN has particularly broad country coverage and additional technology for improving long-distance speeds.

Features and Device Support

Device support is one of the biggest differences in the Proton VPN vs Surfshark comparison.

Surfshark allows unlimited simultaneous connections with a single subscription. This means you can protect phones, computers, tablets, TVs, and other compatible devices without worrying about reaching a fixed connection limit. It is especially useful for families and households with many devices.

Proton VPN’s paid plans support up to 10 devices simultaneously, which is enough for many individual users but less flexible for larger households.

Both offer useful advanced features. Surfshark includes Dynamic MultiHop, CleanWeb, obfuscation, and other privacy tools, while Proton VPN provides Secure Core, NetShield, Stealth, and Tor over VPN.

Surfshark vs Proton VPN for Streaming

Both VPNs can be used for streaming and provide high-speed servers suitable for HD and 4K video. Actual access to individual streaming services can change as platforms update their VPN detection systems.

Surfshark’s unlimited connections are particularly useful if several people in the same household stream on different devices. Proton VPN combines streaming support with broad international server coverage, making it easy to switch between regions.

For most streaming users, either can work well, although Surfshark has an advantage for households using many devices simultaneously.

Pricing and Value

Surfshark generally becomes significantly cheaper per month when you choose a long-term subscription. Its unlimited device policy also increases its value if one account is shared across many personal or household devices.

Proton VPN offers something Surfshark does not: a free VPN plan. The free version has limitations compared with paid plans but provides unlimited data without advertising. Paid Proton VPN plans unlock additional servers and premium features such as Secure Core and streaming support.

Surfshark is generally stronger for long-term value and multiple devices, while Proton VPN is more appealing if you want to start with a capable free option before upgrading.

Verdict

Surfshark is the better choice for users who prioritize value, unlimited simultaneous connections, streaming, and protecting many devices with one subscription. Proton VPN is stronger for privacy-focused users who value open-source apps, Secure Core, a privacy-friendly Swiss jurisdiction, and a useful free plan. Both provide strong security and modern VPN features, but Surfshark is the more practical all-round option for households, while Proton VPN has the edge for users who put privacy and transparency first.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Surfshark have a free plan?

No, only a trial through app stores in some regions; ProtonVPN is the one with a genuinely free, uncapped tier.

Which has open-source apps?

ProtonVPN does; Surfshark's apps are not open source.

Which is better for multiple devices?

Surfshark, since it does not cap the number of simultaneous connections on one subscription.

Which is faster?

Both are fast enough for everyday streaming and browsing; Surfshark's larger server network can help spread load during peak hours.

Which is more beginner-friendly?

Surfshark's interface is slightly simpler out of the box; ProtonVPN's advanced features like Secure Core add a learning curve if you use them.